the value of perspective

Wish You Were Here by Jodi Picoult

Rating: 4 stars (out of 5)

Genre: fiction

Review: This book is a bit of a departure for Picoult, as it doesn't involve an ethical dilemma where both sides are, if not sympathetic, at least fully fleshed out.  Here, the focus is on one character, Diana, who must decide if she really wants what she always thought she wanted from life.

The story starts just when things are starting to get serious in New York City with the COVID-19 pandemic.  Businesses and schools are being shut down and Diana's doctor boyfriend tells her how the hospital is becoming overrun with patients.  Is it too soon for a novel about the pandemic?  Maybe, but not in Picoult's hands.  Perhaps because the first part of the book keeps the pandemic at a remove.  I think the bigger reason (for me at least) is that, because the timeline of the book is largely the spring of 2020, I was able to read about what was going on with a whatever-the-opposite-of-nostalgia is (because I definitely wouldn't wish for those days all over again).  "Oh yeah, I remember all those celebrities singing on YouTube!" "That's right, I had forgotten about wiping down packages!"  "Oh yeah, I remember how we thought this was only going to last two weeks!"

Being able to achieve that kind of perspective is one of the great gifts of fiction and Picoult gives it to us in abundance.

FTC Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for this review.

what comes after

The Living and the Lost by Ellen Feldman

Rating: 4 stars (out of 5)

Genre: historical fiction

Review: As teenagers, Meike and her brother David were sent to America from Germany in the aftermath of Kristallnacht.  Their parents and younger sister Sarah stayed behind.  Meike, who Americanizes her name to Millie, spends WWII at Bryn Mawr, and then as an editor at a magazine.  David enlists as soon as he turns 18.  Both go back to Berlin during the occupation, both to help in various official and unofficial capacities, and to try to make sense of what happened to their family, their city, and their country.

The reader's first question will be: what happened to the rest of the family?  The answer, and Meike's journey to come to terms with it, will haunt readers beyond the last page.  The second question may well be: can Germany and the German people ever recover?  History more or less tells us the answer to that question, but Feldman's exploration of the immediate aftermath of the war will also not soon be forgotten by readers.

Feldman has put all the pieces together to form a worthwhile addition to the genre.  She has a light touch on this weighty topic, but does not shy from addressing the mass hatred and prejudice on both the German and American side.  She brings her scenes and characters to life with heartwrenching feeling.  No reader will escape this book unscathed, and yet it is not so emotional as to get in the way of being able to process the narrative and really think about the larger story.

FTC Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for this review.