Showing posts with label infidelity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label infidelity. Show all posts

Friday, November 13, 2020

real or imagined?

The Mystery of Mrs. Christie by Marie Benedict
Rating: 3.5 stars (out of 5)
Genre: historical fiction
Review: For most of the "real" story of Agatha Christie's disappearance, or at least as much as is publically known, check out this article in the NYTimes Magazine from June 2019, which includes many clips from contemporaneous news articles.  For a fictionalized, but very believable, novel based on the same thing, check out Marie Benedict's latest offering.  Since Mrs. Christie refused to ever speak about what actually happenend, this may be as close as we get to the "truth".

Agatha and her husband take turns telling the story.  Agatha's chapters go back to the past, starting when she met her future husband and going up to the day she disappears.  His start with learning of her disappearance, and they alternate until she is "found" at a Yorkshire spa.  Her chapters are filled with a growing knowledge that the man she married is not the loving husband she thought he was and that perhaps her mother's advice to make him the absolute focus of her life to the exclusion of all else, even their daughter, is not all it's cracked up to be.  His chapters are threaded through with an overlying but vague threat that she made in a letter she left for him before she disappeared that require him to play his part in solving the "mystery".

Benedict tells this story capably, staying very close to the known facts.  So close that one wonders what the reader learns that the newspapers haven't already reported.  Of course, a novel takes us into the characters' heads in a way that journalism can't, but Benedict seems to have left her imagination by the wayside in inhabiting her characters.  Agatha matures throughout the book as she realizes that her marriage is not all that she hoped it would be, and becomes more resolute in her determination to shape her own destiny, but Mr. Christie is very one-dimensional throughout his chapters.  I suppose some characters are easier to write than others, but I hope that for Ms. Benedict's next book, she chooses a subject that alows her more free rein with her generous writing talents.

FTC Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for this review.

Monday, June 1, 2020

Truth? Hard to say.

The Queen of Tuesday: A Lucille Ball Story by Darin Strauss
Rating: 3 stars
Genre: historical fiction
Review:This book is being marketed as a romance, a love story.  I say, really?  There are elements of that in it, to be sure, but in some ways this book is quite the opposite.  The story is two-fold.  One part is a part-fictional, small-part memoir of the author's grandfather, who may or may not have had an affair with Lucille Ball.  They met at a party in New York, before she was nearly as famous as she would later become.  He was established in his real estate career, married, with children.  She too was already married, and focused on making herself (and Desi) a rising star in the acting world.  But they caught each other's attention and a slight obsession followed.  The book jumps through the years, following both, and interspersed with the author's own story of talking to his dying grandfather (the one who, as a younger man, is a character in the larger story - don't worry, it's not as confusing as it sounds).

Do Lucille and the author's grandfather ever get together?  Well, such is the stuff that stories are made of.  Did any of this really happen?  That's a more complicated question.  What is the responsibility of the author of historical fiction to historical fact?  Strauss is completely clear that he doesn't know the truth of the matter, but he also acknowledges fudging such fundamental facts as the day of the week on which I Love Lucy aired.  And why?  That particular detail is absolutely not relevant to the plot, so why bother to change a fact of history.  To me, that calls the entire enterprise of this book into doubt.  Maybe he did that on purpose, since he himself doesn't know the truth of the possible relationship between his grandfather and Lucille Ball.

Setting the absolute truth aside, this is a very readable story.  It follows Lucille Ball through her early struggles with Desi and her career, into her stardom, and through the collapse of her marriage, even as she continues to grow more powerful in Hollywood.  It follows Isidore Strauss, mostly through a family lens, as his children grow and his wife becomes an alcoholic.  Either of these stories separately might have made good reading.  Tying them together is something of a conceit on the author's part, and it doesn't quite work.

FTC Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for this review.

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

all the synonyms for debauchery

Cape May by Chip Cheek
Rating: 3 stars (out of 5)
Genre: historical fiction
Review: In most books, one expects there to be some character growth.  In this book, the characters just get more and more debauched.  Our main characters, Henry and Effie, are newlyweds from Georgia on their honeymoon in Cape May, NJ.  It's September, so the summer resort community is largely empty, but soon Henry and Effie find another young couple in a house down the street.  But their new friends are neither as young nor as innocent Henry and Effie, and soon they find themselves going inexorably down the path to dissipation and lasciviousness until they both doubt whether their marriage will outlast the honeymoon.  Cheek saves most of his answers for the last chapter of the book, where the reader can trace the effects of their licentiousness.

Ultimately, this book is very readable (if you're in the mood for reading about a lot of sex) and the action (pun intended) is fairly continuous, making it feel as though things are moving along at a good pace.  The descriptions of the town and the ocean are evocative (as are the descriptions of the sex) and the characters are believable, if not very likable.  But there's not much movement in this book, either geographical or metaphysical, giving the book a somewhat stagnant feel.

Cheek shows his prowess (I just can't help myself) much more in the last chapter than in all the preceding ones, when he focuses on the emotions of a relationship more than the sex.  He shows definite promise as a novelist (certainly anyone who can write a good sex scene is a promising novelist) but hopefully his future books will focus more on the growth of his characters than on their sex lives.

FTC Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for this review.

Monday, January 3, 2011

in the army

You Know When the Men Are Gone by Shiobhan Fallon
Rating: 3.5 stars (out of 5)
Genre: fiction, short stories
Review: In this collection of short, loosely connected stories, Shiobhan Fallon tries to give the reader an insider's view of military family life. The stories all deal with an army cavalry division deployed from Fort Hood, TX to Iraq; some stories deal with the soldiers, others with their wives, and they all touch on the difficulties military families face both when they are separated for long periods of time, as well as when they are reunited. Some of the stories ring true, like the story of a wife who is concerned that her husband has started an affair with a female soldier while he is overseas. Others strike a false note, like the one where a woman describes listening to the "wildly beating heart" of her fetus.

With other stories, it seems that Fallon wrote herself into a corner she didn't know how to get of. The best example of this is the story of Meg who becomes obsessed with her new neighbor, Natalya. Natalya’s husband is deployed with Meg’s, but Natalya herself is a mystery. At the end of the story, the husbands all return (Meg’s and Natalya’s among them) and that is that. No explanation is given for any of Natalya’s actions, nor is she even mentioned in the rather abrupt conclusion. By and large, though, these stories can be enjoyed by both military and non-military readers. They may resonate with members of the military or their family members, and will give a glimpse into military lives for those of us with no military connection.

FTC Disclaimer: I received this book from the publisher in exchange for this review.